The UK FinTech sector is undergoing a significant transformation, marked by maturation, consolidation, and a more selective investment landscape. Funding is increasingly funnelled towards profit-generating scale-ups, and away from newer entrants.
At the same time, the sector is shaped by a multi-generational workforce with varied perspectives. Meanwhile rapid advancements in AI foster apprehension and excitement. These converging factors make FinTech one of the most dynamic and competitive spaces to work in today. This presents both challenges and opportunities for its leaders.
From our perspective as global FinTech executive search and leadership advisors at Odgers Berndtson these shifts are reshaping the demands placed on leadership. They are also influencing what it takes to lead effectively in this fast-changing sector. Here, we explore the leadership trends that are emerging as a result.
Ethical FinTech leadership
Venture capital funding is now more selective and private equity investors are increasingly targeting fintechs with solid exposure. This is creating a difficult environment for new start-ups. Those attracting funding are typically cash-positive scale-ups.
Amidst these challenges, more FinTech firms are opting to list on the NASDAQ rather than the London Stock Exchange, as the UK navigates more stringent regulation. The need for payments licences, extensive reporting, and compliance demands weigh heavily on FinTech leaders.
In this landscape, we’re seeing leaders with experience in regulated financial services bring a valuable skillset. The ability to operate within defined regulatory frameworks while generating growth. FinTech boards are looking for leaders with high authenticity and who can make ethical decisions. And while balancing ambition and growth with the realities of working in a highly regulated space.
Founder replacements
We are in the midst of the FinTech sector’s maturation. Start-ups are transitioning into scale-ups, requiring different leadership competencies. For many, this requires the founder to step down or step into a board role and appoint a CEO who can take the business through its next stage of growth.
This requires leaders who are commercially driven, capable of shaping market strategies, and adept at understanding customer needs and product-market fit. Navigating risk and regulation becomes crucial, while the founder’s creative, opportunity-led approach typically no longer dominates the new operational and strategic demands.
Boards and investors are looking for CEOs with a broader skillset and deep regulatory expertise. These leaders must also be able to attract and retain the type of talent that can sustain growth and innovation, while maintaining the ‘DNA’ that made the business so attractive in the first place.
A multi-generational workforce
Intergenerational divides are becoming more pronounced for all businesses and noticeably in sectors like FinTech. Here, younger generations with fresh perspectives are working alongside older, more experienced professionals – often from traditional financial services backgrounds.
This diversity in age, experience, and approach can be a powerful asset, but only if integrated effectively. Typically, Gen Z and Millennials prioritise flexibility, technological integration and experimentation. Meanwhile, Boomers bring valuable expertise in regulatory environments and operational effectiveness, but may be more accustomed to traditional structures and leadership styles.
Increasingly, we see FinTech leaders attempt to bridge these divides by emphasising open communication, promoting mentorship opportunities, and encouraging cross-generational collaboration. With less funding and more regulation, FinTech leaders recognise the need to identify and capitalise on the strengths of a multigenerational workforce if they are to succeed.
Leadership team dynamics
As FinTech companies scale, leadership is no longer just about the capabilities of individual leaders but about the dynamics of the entire executive team. Successful scale-ups understand the importance of assembling a leadership team that brings a diverse mix of skills, and generational perspectives to the table.
We are starting to see FinTech companies think about leadership team dynamics as they scale up. Boards are looking for a blend of strategic, operational and ethical considerations. As well as how well team members work together. Do they solve problems cohesively? Are there any unresolved tensions or conflict? Are they aligned and equipped to collectively deliver on the leadership mandate?
Many leadership teams are not optimising their potential due to misalignment of strengths. For example, we recently worked with a FinTech creating an executive team profile to identify the leadership competencies needed to deliver their mandate. This exercise enabled the team to reallocate executive responsibilities for strategic initiatives based on the required strengths, regardless of traditional job roles.
Polarising views on Gen AI
Leading organisations are experiencing a transformational moment due to accelerated interest in AI and Generative AI. 89.6% are increasing their investments in AI, while 64.2% of companies have indicated that AI will be the most transformational technology in a generation. In response, organisations are hiring for the data and AI leadership roles required to prepare their companies for an AI future.
However, this integration of Gen AI has sparked both excitement and nervousness, particularly around issues of data protection and privacy. Generational differences are especially noticeable. Younger professionals are often less concerned about data privacy, while older generations remain cautious about the security implications.
This divergence in attitudes can create tension within the organisation, as leaders grapple with how best to leverage Gen AI while ensuring compliance with stringent data protection regulations. For some FinTechs, AI is seen as a specialised area requiring dedicated focus. Meanwhile, others believe AI represents a fundamental shift in how business can be conducted and AI strategy should be woven into the fabric of every leader’s responsibilities.
This divide in attitudes reflects the broader challenges we see FinTech companies face in incorporating AI. Leaders must now navigate the balance between embracing innovation and safeguarding sensitive information. They must also ensure AI is not seen as a siloed function. It must be an integral part of their commercial and strategic vision. Given the fundamental changes in the sector, the emphasis on leadership capabilities is changing for both the individual and executive team.

- Artificial Intelligence in FinTech
- InsurTech